Redesign or last-time buy? A decision guide with cost comparison
After a discontinuation, there are usually two options: buy once more or redevelop. Which questions drive the decision, how to compare the costs fairly and when a combination of both works best.
Foto: Zan Lazarevic / Unsplash
In brief: Whether a last-time buy or a redesign is more economical is not decided by the component price, but by the total cost over the remaining service life of the product. A last-time buy is usually cheaper if the product only runs for a few more years and demand can be planned. A redesign tends to pay off with a long remaining service life, uncertain demand or when further discontinuations on the same assembly are foreseeable. Often a combination of both is the best solution.
The options at a glance
Last-time buy and redesign are the two ends of a scale. In between there are further options that you should check before deciding.
| Solution | Typical effort | Time required | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Last-time buy | capital, storage, tests | short, until the order deadline | wrong quantity, ageing in storage |
| Replacement component, directly interchangeable | testing and approval | weeks to months | hidden deviations |
| Authorised aftermarket supplier | higher unit price | short | availability and price over the years |
| Purchase on the open market | unit price and test costs | short | counterfeits |
| Minor redesign | adapting circuit or layout, requalification | months | follow-up changes, approval |
| Major redesign | redevelopment of assembly or device | months to years | costs, deadlines, approval |
IEC 62402 explicitly names these solutions and requires that the most economical one be selected according to defined criteria. Before deciding between the extremes, it is therefore worth looking for a suitable replacement component. How the search works is described in the article Received a discontinuation notice – what now?.
The questions that drive the decision
How long must the product remain available?
The most important question. With two or three years of remaining service life, almost everything speaks for a last-time buy. With ten or twenty years, the calculation becomes uncertain: the quantity is hard to forecast, storage costs and ageing grow, and further discontinuations are almost certain.
How reliable is demand?
Stable series with known customers are easy to calculate. Fluctuating demand, new customers or unclear maintenance commitments turn any quantity into a bet. Buying too little means an emergency purchase on the open market, buying too much means written-off goods.
What does a change to the product cost?
In regulated industries, even a small redesign can trigger extensive requalification or re-approval. This is often the largest cost block and the longest time factor. Clarify early which evidence a change requires.
Are further discontinuations foreseeable?
If the discontinued component sits on an assembly with other at-risk components, the calculation changes. A redesign can then solve several problems at once, while each last-time buy only postpones one. A current BOM analysis shows the status of the remaining components.
Can the component be stored for a long time?
Not every component survives ten years in storage without loss of quality. Storage methods and tests cost money and belong in the comparison.
Does a redesign bring additional benefits?
A redesign is not only a cost factor. It can improve functions, reduce manufacturing costs, meet new standards or make the product fit for further years. This benefit belongs honestly in the assessment.
Compare costs fairly
The most common mistake is a skewed comparison: on one side only the component price of the last-time buy, on the other the full development bill. Instead, compare the total costs of both options over the same remaining service life.
| Last-time buy | Redesign |
|---|---|
| Components for the entire remaining demand | development, layout and software adaptation |
| Long-term storage and sample tests | samples, tests and requalification |
| Tied-up capital | approval and customer releases |
| Insurance, inventory, administration | documentation and production adaptation |
| Risk of shortfall and emergency purchase | risk of delays and follow-up changes |
| Write-off of leftover goods | remaining stock of old components that is no longer needed |
A simplified example
A device must remain available for another ten years. A microcontroller is discontinued, the remaining demand is 2,500 units at 12 euros each. Three further components on the same assembly are classified as at risk.
| Item | Last-time buy | Redesign |
|---|---|---|
| Components for the remaining demand | €30,000 | – |
| Long-term storage and sample tests over 10 years | €15,000 | – |
| Tied-up capital, simplified | €6,000 | – |
| Development and layout | – | €60,000 |
| Samples, tests and requalification | – | €40,000 |
| Documentation, production, releases | – | €15,000 |
| Total for this component | €51,000 | €115,000 |
| Expected costs for the three further components | €70,000 | included in the redesign |
| Total over the remaining service life | €121,000 | €115,000 |
Looking only at the microcontroller, the last-time buy is clearly cheaper. Including the foreseeable follow-up discontinuations, both options are almost equal – and the redesign additionally brings ten years of peace on the assembly. The figures are example values. What matters is the principle: calculate over the entire remaining service life and the whole assembly, not over a single component.
How to determine the quantity for the last-time buy is shown in the article Calculating a last-time buy. Which hidden costs a discontinuation also triggers can be read in the article What does obsolescence cost?.
The best solution is often a combination
In practice, the decision is rarely between a pure last-time buy and an immediate redesign. A bridge buy is often the best route: you buy as much as you need until a planned redesign is completed, plus a reserve. This maintains deliverability, reduces tied-up capital and storage risk and gives development time to implement the redesign without pressure.
Even better is to bundle several foreseeable discontinuations in one planned redesign instead of solving each one individually. This only works if the risks of the whole bill of materials are known.
Decision aid at a glance
| Situation | Tendency |
|---|---|
| Short remaining service life, stable demand | last-time buy |
| Long remaining service life, uncertain demand | redesign or bridge buy plus redesign |
| High costs for requalification or approval | rather last-time buy or directly interchangeable replacement |
| Further at-risk components on the assembly | rather redesign, bundle discontinuations |
| Component poorly suited for storage | rather redesign or aftermarket supplier |
| Redesign brings additional benefits | rather redesign |
Document the decision
Record which options were examined, which assumptions the calculation is based on and who decided. This helps with audits and customer questions – and with the next discontinuation. IEC 62402 provides that the criteria for selecting solutions are described in the obsolescence management plan.
Typical mistakes
- The component price is compared with the full development costs
- Storage, tied-up capital and tests are missing from the calculation
- Further at-risk components on the assembly are not considered
- Costs for requalification and approval are underestimated
- The decision is made under time pressure shortly before the order deadline
- A last-time buy is made, but the redesign that is actually needed is never planned
Checklist for the decision
- Remaining service life and maintenance commitments are clarified
- The remaining demand is calculated and agreed
- Replacement components and aftermarket suppliers are checked
- Further risks on the assembly are known
- Costs of both options are calculated over the same remaining service life
- Effort for requalification and approval is assessed
- A bridge buy has been checked as an option
- Assumptions, options and decision are documented
Frequently asked questions
When is a last-time buy worthwhile?
Above all when the product is only delivered or maintained for a few more years, demand can be planned and the component can be stored well. High costs for requalification or approval also speak for a last-time buy.
When is a redesign better?
With a long remaining service life, uncertain demand and when further discontinuations on the assembly are foreseeable. A redesign then solves several problems at once and can also improve functions or manufacturing costs.
What is a bridge buy?
A purchase that does not cover the entire remaining demand, but only the period until a planned redesign is completed, plus a reserve. It combines the security of a last-time buy with a permanent solution.
How much time do I have for the decision?
Usually only until the manufacturer's last order date, often a few months after the discontinuation. Demand calculation, cost comparison and approvals take time. Start immediately after receiving the notice – or better before, when the BOM analysis shows a component as at risk.
Note: the calculation example is simplified, all amounts are example values. Solution options and the term life of need buy according to IEC 62402:2019.
Buy again or redevelop?
In 15 minutes we look together at your case and which solution is the most economical over the remaining service life. Free of charge and without obligation.
Book a free call